The poet sends the image of a rose
from its particular fragrance to the sun.
— Robert Duncan
Crosses of Harmony and Disharmony

Robert Duncan came to the foreground of New American poetry in the 1960s with the publication of his second collection of poems, The Opening of the Field (1960).1 His poetry was hugely influenced by Charles Olson and the concepts about poetic composition that he explored in the manifesto “Projective Verse.”2 Olson proposed a new kind of poetry which could break free from formal traditions of rhyme and syntax and rely instead on the organic sensibilities of the poet such as his/her/their sense of breath and ear for language. Alongside Olson, Duncan was a part of the Black Mountain school of poetry, where he taught in 1956, and a key figure in the San Francisco Renaissance, which included other poets such as Jack Spicer and Robin Blaser. Given this history, there is ample work which explores Duncan’s poetry in relation to Olson, and he is also well known for his book on the modernist poet H.D., published posthumously as The H.D. Book in 2011.3 But there are other aspects of Duncan’s writing which remain understudied—such as the philosophical traditions that influenced his poetry and the collaborative projects that he made with his longtime partner, the painter Jess Collins.

In his writings, Duncan was most influenced by the works of the philosopher Alfred North Whitehead, who pioneered the school of thought known as “process philosophy.” This was a theory about the metaphysics of reality, which according to Whitehead is composed of dynamic webs and relations that exist between all phenomena, instead of being made up of static and isolated, material objects. Duncan aimed to encapsulate some of these ideas in his own poetic composition and to write poetry that could reenact the complex webs of relations that exist in language, the fluidity of consciousness, or the ongoing nature of processes in reality. Some of this influence is addressed by James Maynard in his book Robert Duncan and the Pragmatist Sublime (2018), which also discusses the poet’s reception of the pragmatist thinkers William James and John Dewey.4 Along these lines, I conducted an archival research project for Lost & Found: The CUNY Poetics Document Initiative at the University at Buffalo in 2024 to investigate whether Whitehead’s influence was also present in Duncan’s collaboration with Jess. At the archives, I evaluated manuscript materials, artwork, ephemera, audio, correspondence, and other visual materials belonging to Jess. Through this evaluation, I was able to deduce that a recurring pattern emerged in many of their collaborative works—whether in handmade books, loose sketches, posters for events, cards, handwritten poems, or small colored notebooks—which is that Duncan provided the words and Jess produced accompanying images. This resulted in a kind of ongoing formal play between their respective media and reflected much of Whitehead’s ideas about process philosophy.

To provide a glimpse of these collaborations, three of the archival materials from this project are gathered here: two pages from A Book of Resemblances (1966) and a poster by Jess, to convey a range of the different kinds of playful relationships that they set up between words and images.5 The first archival object (fig. 1) is a page from A Book of Resemblances and part of a sequence titled “Of the Art,” which is completely free from words and drawn by Jess. The second archival object (fig. 2) presents a fuller version of the hybrid form created by Duncan and Jess, where the words and images come together to meet on a single page. Finally, the third archival object (fig. 3) is a poster by Jess, where he inverses the usual dynamic of influence from Duncan’s poetry to his visual art by experimenting with language in his own way and producing a collage with words.

Figure 1. “Of the Art,” A Book of Resemblances, 1966. University at Buffalo: Rare & Special Books, The Poetry Collection, Robert Duncan Collection. 11″ w x 13.5″ h.

In the first archival object (fig. 1), we find the image of a woman who is seen lying down with another person’s hand gently placed over her—probably her lover’s. She appears to be fast asleep, with eyes closed, and is completely at rest, our gaze almost an intrusion on this moment. This image was drawn by Jess in “Of the Art,” and was partially in response to Duncan’s poetry about bodies in that section. It is but one example of the many quietly and intimately drawn sketches by Jess which were inserted throughout different sections of the book, in between Duncan’s handwritten poems and poetic prose, often responding to the themes implied by them. This arrangement expands the reader’s imagination by proliferating rich modes of interpretation between such visual sequences and the pages of writing around them, or even when they are taken separately, as each part could tell a story of its own. These images also provide spaces of silence for the reader to pause, think, reflect, ruminate, and speculate about the meaning of the poems they accompany. As a result, an active mode of reading and reflection is invoked by this mode of composition, and some of the core ideas of process philosophy, according to which Duncan considered poetry to be an ongoing process, are brought to life.

The second archival object is an excerpt from the poem titled “Five Pieces,” which directly illustrates the interplay between words by Duncan and images by Jess on a single page. Here, two large hands appear to have grown organically out of the stanzas in the poem and sit beside them. James Maynard referred to this method of composition as Duncan’s “Poetics of Organism,” where he is concerned more with the wholeness of the structure, rather than the parts which make up the whole. What is striking to note here is that Jess participates in the co-creation of Duncan’s vision by offering his visual art as extensions to the world of language.

Figure 2. “Five Pieces,” A Book of Resemblances, 1966. University at Buffalo: Rare & Special Books, The Poetry Collection, Robert Duncan Collection. 11″ w x 13.5″ h.

The hands unfold from the stanzas and function as visual components, extending the poem’s environment and producing an ecosystem of relations around it, where meaning is created between the words and images. According to Maynard, this is one of the most Whiteheadian elements of Duncan’s poiesis and is an adoption of the concept known as “extensive continuum.”6 Maynard writes that “Duncan’s conception of the book as an extended formal structure […] owes a great deal to the pragmatist view of the world as an open-ended totality, and in particular to Whitehead’s theory of the universe as a vast system of extensive relationships […] No poem is ever complete in itself; instead, each reverberates endlessly in multiple configurations of potentially meaningful relationships both internally and externally.”7  The second section of the poem is as follows:

The nakedness changes.
Each body stript bare
changes; over.

The hair like a harp string
to the touch
trembles with sound:

bell-tones float
over the water.

The human body is one of the central subjects in this poem, and its fleshiness, especially when taken in naked form, is considered to be an ever-changing and malleable entity that responds to how it is “stript bare.” Even the most sensitive of contact, for instance with a strand of hair, can lead to “trembles with sound” which produces a set of musical notes. The body and its parts that occur throughout this poem act as vessels for taking in and letting out music. This also alludes toward some of the ideas in Olson’s “Projective Verse,” where the body is considered an organic vessel for both sound and breath, hence the source of language itself. Therefore, poetry emerges out of the body, and Duncan embraced this fact almost with a kind of spiritual dictum in his poems. Following this theme, a smaller fragment from the third section reads as follows:

The sleeping hands
lie across the strings of sensation
like trees in a high wind
bent to the ground.

These lines embody and make manifest some blurring of boundaries between one’s physical hands, the strings which are the source of music, and the moving trees in nature “bent to the ground.” It is as if all of them are blended by Whiteheadian metaphysical forces of the universe which stream through them. What we find in these archival objects is, then, a deep engagement of process philosophy by Duncan and Jess as they weave together words and images to produce a third kind of object, hovering between poetry and visual art, but which exceeds both categories.

Figure 3. “The Inside Inside,” Study 1, 1968. University at Buffalo: Rare & Special Books, The Poetry Collection, Robert Duncan Collection. Works by Jess, 1952–1996, JESS023. 10.75″ w x 13.25″ h.

Finally, the third archival object is a standalone piece by Jess, which is a poster made of ink and paper (fig. 3). A cat sits on top of a pile of books and appears to be reading one of them, peering into its surface, as if to access what’s underneath. There is a surreal aspect to this cat reading a book, just as there is a dreamlike quality to the words “the inside inside” which floats underneath the table in the poster. They seem to signify that there are greater depths to reality than what meets the eye. Jess sets up a playful relationship between the gestures of the cat and the metaphysical themes of the poster, where the words symbolize that beneath the surface of our material world lie the ontological depths of reality. These are also ideas from process philosophy, which Jess has brought to life by experimenting with language and using words in the poster as one would use images in a collage. Thus, through their poetry and visual art, Duncan and Jess have shown that, at times, some of the most abstract ideas in philosophy are best represented by works of imagination which are wild, open, free from the demands of logic, and robed in the garments of beauty.

Acknowledgments: I would like to thank the Lost & Found community at the Graduate Center, CUNY, who supported this research from its earliest stages with fellowship, guidance, and consistent care. I’d also like to thank the archivist James Maynard at the University at Buffalo: The Poetry Collection for helping me throughout this project. Finally, many thanks to Lynn Lasota for aid in handling archival materials. 

All images related to Duncan © the Robert Duncan Collection and used by permission.

All images by Jess © the Jess Collins Trust and used by permission.

Notes

  1. Robert Duncan, The Opening of the Field, (New York: Grove Press, 1960). ↩︎
  2. Charles Olson, “Projective Verse,” Collected Prose, edited by Donald Allen and Benjamin Friedlander Berkeley: University of California Press, 1997), 239–49. ↩︎
  3. Robert Duncan, The H.D. Book, ed. Michael Boughn and Victor Coleman (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2011). ↩︎
  4. James Maynard, Robert Duncan and the Pragmatist Sublime (Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press, 2018). ↩︎
  5. Robert Duncan, A Book of Resemblances: Poems, 1950–1953, ill. Jess [Collins] (New Haven, CT: Henry Wenning, 1966). ↩︎
  6. Maynard, Pragmatist Sublime, pp. 80-81. ↩︎
  7. Maynard, Pragmatist Sublime, pp. 93. ↩︎